Ever look back at an artist’s catalog and start to think “this was the golden era.” or “this is better than that?” Critics selected John Mellencamp’s biggest hits. Check out the list, do you agree?

1. “Jack & Diane”

2. “Small Town”

3. “Pink Houses”

4. “Crumblin’ Down”

5. “Hurts So Good”

6. “The Authority Song”

7. “Lonely Ol’ Night”

8. “Key West Intermezzo (I Saw You First)”

9. “Paper in Fire”

10. “Check It Out”

11. “Wild Night”

12. “Cherry Bomb”

13. “Rain on the Scarecrow”

14. “Hand to Hold On To”

15. “Pop Singer”